← Back to front page
Europe · General news · The Independent

Criticism of draft Cop31 deal text shows how tough climate negotiations will be

Published by The Independent · United Kingdom 41 min ago
Related: World gathers in Antalya for Cop31 climate conference
Related: World gathers in Antalya for Cop31 climate conference · The Independent

Detailed summary

The first week of the UN’s flagship climate conference in Antalya was marked by logistical problems and transport chaos, writes Liz Cookman. The stakes are high, given a year of heatwaves, but the draft has been criticised for lacking clarity

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

A first draft of text for a deal at Cop31 has been circulated to delegates, drawing swift criticism from climate campaigners and reflecting the wider disarray that has characterised the largest ever UN climate summit.

As the event entered its second week on Monday, negotiations shifted from technical discussions to high-level political talks, with the cover decision intended to set out the key outcomes countries hope to secure.

But the 18-page, 144-paragraph draft appears to be a sprawling compilation of most of the competing priorities put forward by countries participating in the negotiations, quickly categorised by observers as being too long, lacking clarity, and with “a lot of weeds that need to be pulled out,” according to Mohamed Adow of think tank Power Shift Africa.

It is “best described as a mish-mash of contradictory proposals that stand little chance of making it into the final outcome text,” says Asad Rehman, chief executive of Friends of the Earth.

“The draft text makes the right diagnosis, but the medicine it offers could have deadly side effects,” adds Romain Ioualalen of advocate group Oil Change International. “You cannot diagnose fossil fuels as the sickness and let fossil fuels be part of the care.”

The draft contains two formulations on fossil fuels: one reiterating the commitment to “transition away” from them that was agreed at Cop28, and another calling for their phase-out altogether. Both could be dropped from the final agreement, with negotiators facing a Friday deadline to reach a deal, although previous climate summits have frequently run over time.

Defending the inclusion of competing proposals, Australia’s climate minister – and president of the negotiations – Chris Bowen, told a press conference on Monday: “Frankly, if we only talk about what we all agree on...

"We need to move the ⁠dial, which means having the…

Opening of the article, excerpted from The Independent. To read the rest, open the article on the publisher's site.

Read the full article on The Independent Sign in to save

MarketNews shows the headline and summary published by the outlet. The full article is on the publisher's website. (www.independent.co.uk)

Also worth reading