← 返回首页
美国 · 综合新闻 · The Boston Globe

Mass. rejected all-party primaries. But what about majority voting?

来源:The Boston Globe · 美国 9 小时前
Mass. rejected all-party primaries. But what about majority voting?
The Boston Globe

详细摘要

Hats off to the reformers behind the all-party primary ballot initiative, otherwise known as Question 3. Although their proposal was turned down by Massachusetts voters on Nov. 3,…

Eric Maskin, a Nobel laureate in economics, is a professor at Harvard and a member of the advisory board of Better Choices for Democracy.

Hats off to the reformers behind the all-party primary ballot initiative, otherwise known as Question 3. Although their proposal was turned down by Massachusetts voters on Nov. 3, they correctly identified a serious problem with elections in our state: We voters aren’t being offered enough choice on the menu of candidates.

Consider this year’s US Senate race. Incumbent Ed Markey defeated Seth Moulton in the Democratic primary; John Deaton ran unopposed in the Republican primary. And so Markey squared off against Deaton (and a couple of fringe contenders) in the general election. But these two candidates were poles apart ideologically — especially on health care, energy, and climate. Voters would have benefited from the possibility of choosing a strong third candidate with positions in the middle, someone like Moulton.

Yet they didn’t have this option because Moulton wasn’t on the ballot in November. Despite the fact that he could have run under a third party, he had good reason not to — under our current first-past-the-post voting system (in which each voter chooses one candidate and the contender with the most votes wins), he’d have faced almost certain excommunication from the Democratic Party as punishment for taking votes from Markey.

Nor would the voting system proposed by Question 3 — had it been in place — have succeeded in getting Moulton on the general election ballot. In an all-party primary involving Deaton, Markey, and Moulton, we’d expect Markey (with the support of most Democratic voters) and Deaton (with votes from practically all Republicans) to be the top-two finishers. Thus, the Question 3 system would send them alone to the November election. It would simply replicate the ballot that voters actually faced, minus the fringe candidates.

Still, there is a way of expanding Massachusetts voters’ options beyond the…

Under…

A…

文章开头,摘自The Boston Globe。如需阅读全文,请前往媒体网站。

在 The Boston Globe 阅读全文 登录后可收藏

MarketNews 仅展示媒体发布的标题和摘要,全文请在出版方网站阅读。 (www.bostonglobe.com)

推荐阅读